jm428's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 179975157 | Hi, the reason you got the bot message above is because while moving around the map you accidentally dragged part of a sidewalk far from where it was supposed to be. I've fixed it so you can ignore the message from the bot. |
|
| 179922656 | Hi, thanks for contributing to OSM!
|
|
| 179881105 | Yeah you are right that the grayed values are usually the implied defaults so it is strange that they are all set to yes. I asked some people who are more experienced than I am. One said they usually don't set the access tag unless it is signed but said that access=destination is most correct (except for the section connecting the sidewalk to the road, if there is a sidewalk, because pedestrians can use that to get to the road). The other said "Driveways can be assumed to be access=private (+access:delivery=yes), but it doesn't hurt to tag that access explicitly." So I would probably leave the access tag blank and assume that whoever is using the data knows how driveways should be used, but using access=private or access=destination isn't wrong either. |
|
| 179881105 | according to the wiki, access=yes means "The public has an official, legally-enshrined right of access; i.e., it's a right of way." which I don't think is true here.
|
|
| 179784211 | Hi, thanks for contributing to OSM. I've removed the unmarked crossings because those should only be used when crossing a regular road. When crossing a driveway for someone's house the sidewalk should continue. |
|
| 179766378 | Having the footpath connected to the road there was technically correct, because someone walking on the footpath would be able to start walking on the road once the footpath ended.
|
|
| 179767253 | Hi, thanks for contributing to OSM!
If the playground, field, and track do not have official names, those name tags can also be removed. Here is an excerpt from the wiki which explains more:
|
|
| 179564249 | Hi, you added the same road three different times in these three changesets:
|
|
| 178778612 | Hi, thanks for contributing to OSM. For future reference, when adding a marked crossing, there also needs to be a marked crossing node that connects to the road that the crosswalk is crossing.
|
|
| 177480214 | Hi, just so you know we aren't allowed to use Google Maps or Google Streetview as a source because of copyright reasons, so don't put any google links in your changeset comments |
|
| 153609692 | Got it, thanks! |
|
| 177107257 | That makes sense. I initially hesitated with 'village' because I don’t see it as a distinct settlement. I’m still figuring out when to use the various place values.
|
|
| 153609692 | I am curious why you classified the paths in the Salem Common as tracks. I haven't been there but in the imagery they look like regular paths |
|
| 177107257 | Hi, I am curious how you decided to classify places, because I don't think some of these places fit the definition of a village. Amherst Center for example doesn't fit the wiki definition of a village in my opinion: node/13388820240 |
|
| 82725523 | Hi, in this changeset you changed the name of the terminal from terminal 2A to terminal 2. I think the correct name is Terminal 2A, because terminal 2 already exists as a relation with this terminal and terminal 2B included in it: relation/8469252
|
|
| 176881425 | Hi, I changed it back because roads should not be split into two unless there is a physical barrier separating the road |
|
| 137260710 | Ah, that makes sense, thanks! |
|
| 176906454 | Hi, I notice you changed one of the roads from a track to a residential road. Read the wiki about what a residential road is: highway=residential
|
|
| 176644269 | Hi, a shoulder cycleway means that there is a shoulder on the road that you can bike in (see the wiki for a picture example: cycleway=*), but I don't think there is any shoulder on this road so I removed the cycleway tag you added.
|
|
| 137260710 | Hi, I am curious why you added the name "Lighthouse Hill Road" to this building: way/1058591316 A different user has added that name to many of the buildings on that road, which seems incorrect to me but I was unsure because you also added that name to a building. |