ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 173474249 | You have missed tagging layer=-1 to this an the other tunnel speed cameras you added
|
|
| 172948409 | Review as requested: way/1436136343 is crossing multiple buildings and does not match the bing imagery that you listed as the source
|
|
| 172594321 | I think the shop tag is also wrong, shop=supermarket seems wrong
|
|
| 171442530 | These are not residential roads - they are driveways
|
|
| 171442885 | These are not residential roads - they are driveways
|
|
| 171337411 | Personal identifying information does not belong in OSM. Additionally the information appears to be fake
|
|
| 171337115 | You previously added this McDonalds and it was removed as fantasy mapping after you didn't answer questions on that changeset. It still does not appear at https://mcdonalds.co.nz/find-us/restaurants and in aerial imagery looks to be a residential property. Additionally your changeset comment is non-sensical. Is this a genuine McDonalds? |
|
| 169542645 | Thank you for addressing this.
|
|
| 171001802 | Do these trees you are adding really have an name? It appears as if you are adding a generic "Pohon" (which I understand to be a translation of tree) to every tree. This is not correct or needed, see osm.wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions
|
|
| 170809378 | Additionally some tags have been updated an not others (check_date; contact:*; email; mobile etc) which make this POI a weird combination of two businesses
|
|
| 169644353 | Please do not use GSV as a source for OSM edits - it is expressly forbidden in their terms of service, see osm.wiki/Google
|
|
| 169892054 | The correct way to tag a destroyed building is to use a life cycle prefix (see osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix#Stages_of_decay) instead of tagging as an area. Also please don't change the name to a description: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|
|
| 169584545 | Can you please advise what the source is for these peaks you are adding? Your changesets just list LINZ NZ Aerial Imagery and the peaks seem to not match the LINZ Height Point data from April 2025 |
|
| 169542645 | Many of the names you added: "Staff Only", "Concrete Pad" etc do not appear to be actual names (as per osm.wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions). Please use access/descriptions tags etc instead
|
|
| 169584122 | Why are you tagging latitude and longitude? They are implicit and do not need to be tagged: wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:longitude
|
|
| 169371996 | Have you edited the correct building? This is 399 not 59 |
|
| 169367985 | Why have you changed the building name? As seen in https://www.mapillary.com/app/?pKey=1028780289213963 the building is named "Pasadena Buildings" (and certainly not "=" which you changed it to) |
|
| 169316581 | You've removed this road with no source tagged and apparently LINZ NZ Aerial Imagery used which definitely shows tracks across the dry river bed. LINZ topo maps also show a track here. Additionally there was a ford tagged which you left.
|
|
| 167852506 | Source was "survey;Mapillary" |
|
| 167375824 | Correction: source was LINZ NZ Aerial Imagery |