Btw: I just had a quick glance at some of your updates and it looks like it would be a good idea if you were to have a thorough reading of everything concerning access=* because those tags describe legal restraints and do not convey if something is usable by some mode of transport

Hi :)

if nothing else happened than you don't need to worry. A couple hundred mappers across Europe are now slightly annoyed at the large bbox but that's all.

Safe travels, happy mapping and if there are any questions regarding anything OSM just come round the forum at c.osm.org or one of the chat groups

Hi again,

since you like to work with water and landuse it would be very nice of you to learn about osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177327429

Hello again

Please DO NOT delete objects you intend to change. The building just needed refinement. The service way only needed a bit of adjustment.

Remeber osm.wiki/Keep_the_history

and please do not connect highways and landuse like you did here. Highways should only connect to barriers and other highways. Placing the barrier on the landuse isn't helpful at all.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177316939

Moin :)

du hast hier einen Adress-node verschoben:

node/9985967900

guck mal bitte, ob das Absicht war.

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177317169

reverted in changeset/177317146

sorry. forgot the comment. reverted what looks like intentional deletion of military objects. user doesn't respond to comments...

(hopefully) reverted in changeset/177316990

reverted in changeset/177316714

Hallo Oberlausitzer42,

Feld und Wirtschaftswege werden bei OSM nicht als highway=cycleway erfasst. Sei doch bitte so gut und lass den Weg als highway=track mit den Einschränkungen die durch die Beschilderung gegeben sind.

Besten Gruß
silversurfer83

Hi :)

I don't think this worked as intended.

Please read place=island carefully and try again.

If neccessary, please reach out for help. Theres always people at c.osm.org or in chat groups like those on Signal

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177294139

Guten Morgen und danke für die schnelle Rückmeldung.

Üblicherweise werden die allermeisten "Fz Klasse XY frei" Zusatzzeichen über ein einfaches "yes" freigegeben.

Die Eigenschaften hier dürften am Ende, wenn Landwirtschaft frei auch beschildert ist, folgendermaßen aussehen:

highway=* (kommt auf die Art der Straße an)
vehicle=no
bicycle=designated
motor_vehicle=yes;agricultural
bicycle_road=yes
maxspeed=30
source:maxspeed=DE:bicycle_road
traffic_sign=DE:"Kfz-Verkehr frei",1026-36;244.1

Hi :)

motor_vehicle=designated sagt so viel wie "diese Straße ist per Verkehrszeichen für Motorfahrzeuge vorgesehen" und das widerspricht der Fahrradstraße ja diametral. Das motor_vehicle=yes halte ich für passender.

Interessant wäre, wie genau die Straße beschildert ist. Also wirklich die exakte Kombination an Verkehrszeichen.

Grüße
silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177215755

Hi :)

du kannst die grauen Punkte des Ackers zur Straße hin, wo jetzt Feuerwehr ist, mit rechtsklick und dann auf den Doppelpfeil von den anderen Fläche lösen und sie dann so verschieben, dass du Platz für die neue Fläche hast, wo jetzt feuerwehr ist. Die neue Fläche wird dann amenity=fire_station und das Gebäude wird building=fire_station

Bei Fragen immer raus damit

silversurfer83
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177176976

HI there

what's the reason for deleting this object?

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177191156

HI there

what's the reason for deleting this object?

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177191156

Hello George and Aethonatic,

thank you for the thorough explanation. I did read it all, indeed.

- It is kinda exciting to know that our data is used this way. The reasons may be many and I will not speculate at this point.

- We have guidelines set down in our wiki on how certain features are to be "mapped". We can not allow for every commercial data consumer to deviate from these guidelines just so their use case works. It doesn't work that way around.

- Still, OSM is a collection of many views and if these objects are clearly named that way in your facility, that's fine. One could argue, that if they aren't signposted, loc_name=* would be better for many.

- taking the Circular Platform as example: I do not believe highway=services is a good choice here.

- if an object is not there (anymore) you are certainly free to delete it from the database. To take the Platform again: There werde OSM-Objects in that place which you (or your colleague) have removed and put your own objects there. This is not the way. If something isn't well drawn or placed you are free to modify it so it better fits reality on the ground.

Sorry to cut short here. Tight schedule.

Maybe it isn't too bad an idea for you to move to c.osm.org to discuss your intentions.

cheers

Hi there :)

I don't quite understand what you're trying to map here.

Have you had a look at wiki.osm.org before adding things like "Circular Platform" or "Nitrogen Station"?

it seems like you're misusing name=* as description and you deleted perfectly fine OSM objects to replace them with your versions which is against "Keep the History".

I suggest you swing by the forum to get some input on what you're trying to do at c.osm.org

cheers

hi

access=no bedeutet, dass kein Zugang für niemanden besteht. Ist das an dieser Stelle korrekt?

Und noch eine Bitte: Deine Kommentare sind teils noch ausbaufähig. Check mal osm.wiki/DE:Good_changeset_comments

cheers
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177111138

Hi :)

die Daten der Schule insgesamt werden am umliegenden Gelände erfasst. Dieses Gebäude ist nur ein Gebäude, in dem ggf. Unterricht stattfindet.

Bei Fragen immer raus damit. Details zu vielen Dingen findest du im Wiki unter wiki.osm.org

happy mapping
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177113365